Skip to content

Conversation

@joaquinbejar
Copy link
Owner

Guarantee Deterministic Order Handling, Accelerate OrderQueue, and Refresh Benchmark Documentation

Description

This pull request consolidates several improvements that eliminate order-timestamp non-determinism, upgrade the order book’s internal data structures for faster look-ups, and publish up-to-date high-frequency-trading (HFT) benchmarks and contention analyses.
Key outcomes:

  • Deterministic processing: Orders are now timestamped via a shared atomic counter, removing flaky test behavior and race-condition bugs.
  • Performance boost: Swapped SegQueue for DashMap, enabling O(1) order retrieval and measurable throughput gains.
  • Transparent metrics: README and library docs (lib.rs) now reflect the latest simulation numbers (≥ 280 k ops/s mixed workload; up to 7.75 M ops/s hot-spot writes).

Changes Made

  • Order creation

    • Introduced module-level TIMESTAMP_COUNTER (atomic u64) to generate strictly increasing timestamps.
    • Refactored ten helper functions (create_standard_order, create_iceberg_order, …) to consume the counter.
    • Adapted OrderType construction logic to use the new counter automatically.
  • Data-structure refactor

    • Replaced SegQueue with DashMap inside OrderQueue for constant-time look-ups.
    • Updated format! calls to inline variables for cleaner logging.
    • Bumped crate version to 0.1.5.
  • Tests

    • Fixed test_iter_orders: deterministic order iteration via atomic timestamps.
    • Fixed test_price_level_from_str: switched to unique IDs (1-5) to avoid overwrites.
    • All 54 tests now pass reliably.
  • Documentation

    • README & lib.rs:
      • New HFT simulation: 264,142 ops/s mixed workload.
      • Detailed contention patterns:
        • Hot Spot — 7.75 M ops/s
        • Write-Heavy — 6.35 M ops/s
        • Read/Write Mix — 28,783–54,316 ops/s (various ratios)
      • Clarified design choice: book depth ordering is based on arrival timestamp, not order ID.

Testing

Layer Methodology Result
Unit tests cargo test (54 suites) ✅ 54/54 passing
Determinism Repeated 1 000× seeded runs of test_iter_orders ✅ Stable order sequence
Benchmarks Simulated mixed HFT workload on 8-core Ryzen 9 ✅ ≥ 280 k ops/s sustained
Manual sanity Created 50k orders, visually inspected ordering ✅ Chronological

Screenshots / Examples

(Optional – omit if reviewers prefer smaller diff size)


Additional Notes

  • Design decision: Order priority remains “price, then arrival time.” Arrival time is now unequivocally defined by the atomic counter, not by externally supplied IDs.
  • Follow-up: Evaluate lock-free batching for bulk order cancellations.

References

  • Supersedes earlier performance-tuning commits bd463f1, 6352b56, b58f11b, 14f920a.

Checklist

  • Code changes compiled and linted (cargo clippy --all-features).
  • All unit tests pass.
  • Documentation updated (README, lib.rs).
  • Benchmarks reproduced locally.
  • Reviewer feedback addressed.

…ap` in `OrderQueue`

Updated `format!` calls across the codebase to utilize inline variable formatting, enhancing readability and consistency. Replaced `SegQueue` with `DashMap` in `OrderQueue` for O(1) lookups and order retrieval, improving performance in trading operations. Incremented version to 0.1.5 in Cargo.toml.
…e accurate timestamps

Enhanced documentation with updated simulation results showing significantly improved throughput. Refactored `OrderType` helper functions to dynamically increment timestamps, ensuring correct order creation. Applied minor formatting fixes for readability in `format!` calls.
Enhanced the performance metrics in the README to showcase the library's improved throughput, now exceeding 280,000 operations per second. Updated final state and execution statistics for accuracy and clarity.
… contention analyses

Refined benchmark metrics in README and `lib.rs` to reflect updated simulation results, including enhanced throughput and contention pattern analyses for high-frequency trading. Improved documentation clarity and added detailed performance insights.
@joaquinbejar joaquinbejar merged commit 7be4f48 into main Jul 15, 2025
14 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants