Skip to content

Stars - Look Away#15

Open
Insan3e wants to merge 1 commit intoEncore-Developers:mainfrom
Insan3e:Stars
Open

Stars - Look Away#15
Insan3e wants to merge 1 commit intoEncore-Developers:mainfrom
Insan3e:Stars

Conversation

@Insan3e
Copy link

@Insan3e Insan3e commented Jul 4, 2024

Chart Verification PR

Stars - Look Away

cover

Instruments and difficulties charted

Instrument Easy Medium Hard Expert
Drums Yes Yes Yes Yes
Bass Yes Yes Yes Yes
Lead Yes Yes Yes Yes
Vocals No No No Yes
Pro Drums Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pro Bass Yes Yes Yes Yes
Pro Lead Yes Yes Yes Yes

Additional details

@tposejank tposejank added the pending review Song is pending review label Jul 4, 2024
@WowItsOnlyConnor
Copy link
Collaborator

Hi, won't go too in-depth in this review unless I know you'll see this, if you do please respond with a comment. I don't want to waste time reviewing a chart that I don't know will be fixed, respectfully

So possibly major issue-

  • There seems to be duplicate track names for Classic and Pad, so there's a PART DRUMS with pad charting and a PART DRUMS with standard rock band charting, I'm not sure how well the game handles this so please remove the PART track names with the charting from Moonscraper(?)

  • You're missing the [music_end] and [end] events in your EVENTS track, at [music_end] where either the music ends or where you would want the crowd to begin cheering in something like rock band, and [end] when you want the game to go to the score screen.

  • On pad vocals there are really minor pitch errors, and some patterns should be adjusted to be played with both hands instead of one hand on the right/left side of the highway

  • There may be minor pitch accuracy errors on both bass charts, mainly in the chorus

  • There are no drum fill makers on classic drums, meaning the player can't activate overdrive

Otherwise I don't exactly see much issue with everything else, though you should add your charter credits in info.json and I think you have your intensity ratings (the difficulty rating) setup wrong. I'd also chart easier difficulties for Pad Vocals just so it's full controller band all difficulties.

@WowItsOnlyConnor WowItsOnlyConnor added needs revising Edits are necessary and removed pending review Song is pending review labels Oct 8, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

needs revising Edits are necessary

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants