Skip to content

Tally Hall - Mucka Blucka#13

Open
Insan3e wants to merge 1 commit intoEncore-Developers:mainfrom
Insan3e:TH
Open

Tally Hall - Mucka Blucka#13
Insan3e wants to merge 1 commit intoEncore-Developers:mainfrom
Insan3e:TH

Conversation

@Insan3e
Copy link

@Insan3e Insan3e commented Jul 3, 2024

Chart Verification PR

Tally Hall - Mucka Blucka

cover

Instruments and difficulties charted

Instrument Easy Medium Hard Expert
Drums No No No Yes
Bass No No No No
Lead No No No Yes
Vocals No No No Yes
Pro Drums No No No Yes
Pro Bass No No No No
Pro Lead No No No Yes

Additional details

🐔

@tposejank tposejank added the pending review Song is pending review label Jul 3, 2024
@WowItsOnlyConnor
Copy link
Collaborator

WowItsOnlyConnor commented Jul 28, 2025

Pad Lead -

  • There are illegal chords everywhere.
  • The ending pattern needs to be adjusted to accommodate for gamepad players.

Pad Drums -

  • Typically, drum rolls are charted as trills to imitate using both hands to play a part of a drum.
  • At some points charting just kick and snare took priority here, when just kick and snare are prioritized, it's still charted on the first two lanes, meaning it's done on the player's off hand.

Pad Vocals -

  • There are unnecessary chords when it's just one voice
  • Some notes in the song aren't charted

Pro Drums -

  • There are no drum fills, meaning the drummer can't activate overdrive at all.
  • Some drum rolls take priority over having the hihat charted and others don't

Pro Lead -

  • You charted vocals on Lead, which is fine technically but you actually charted the lead on Pad Lead... however at the end of the song the organ is charted for some reason?
  • Also since this is charted to Vocals, there are numerous inconsistencies between this and Pad Vocals that don't make sense.

Other Errors -

  • Your info.json is outdated. Use the newer format [insert link to the newer formatted json]
  • You are missing your own charter name, the date the song released, and the album name
  • The song length is 410 seconds, which is about 7 minutes... the song is 1 minute 38 seconds
  • The difficulty for Bass is "0", which is added up ingame, meaning that the difficulty for Bass is 1, however there is no Bass chart.
  • Adding to the above, there is very audible Bass audio, not charting all instruments a song has to offer is heavily frowned upon.

If this gets a response I'll provide a more in-depth explanation of the errors found, I'm respectfully not going through the effort of listing every error I've found if I don't know if the charter will even notice the requested changes

@WowItsOnlyConnor WowItsOnlyConnor added needs revising Edits are necessary and removed pending review Song is pending review labels Jul 28, 2025
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

needs revising Edits are necessary

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants