implement #180 60m/DEV HttpClient should be recreated properly.

[DenisZhukovski]

No description provided.

[DenisZhukovski]

No code review comments to add.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: src/Core/DefaultState/DefaultStateAnalyzer.cs
Category: Bugs
Severity: High
Title: Unhandled Exception in Analyze Method
Description: The Analyze method catches generic exceptions but doesn't handle specific cases, which can obscure the true cause of issues and lead to silent failures.
Recommendation: Handle specific exceptions (e.g., TargetInvocationException) in the Analyze method to provide better error reporting and to allow for debugging during the object instantiation process.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: src/Core/Extensions/DecompilerExtensions.cs
Category: Code Quality
Severity: Medium
Title: Redundant Else Statement
Description: The code contains an unnecessary else statement after a return statement, reducing overall readability and maintainability of the code.
Recommendation: Remove the redundant else statement for cleaner and more concise code. The return statement covers the needed functionality without additional nesting.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: src/Core/Extensions/ObjectExtensions.cs
Category: Maintainability
Severity: Medium
Title: Unclear Separation of Concerns
Description: The method combining both state evaluation and object construction could lead to tight coupling, making the method hard to maintain and test in isolation.
Recommendation: Refactor this method into separate components: one for state evaluation and another for managing the construction of objects to improve maintainability and cohesion.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: tests/ObjectToTest.UnitTests/ToTestTests.cs
Category: Maintainability
Severity: Medium
Title: Test Class Structure is Complex
Description: The Test Class contains a mix of utility functions and test cases that are not separated clearly, making it difficult for new developers to navigate and contribute effectively.
Recommendation: Refactor the Test Class to group related test cases together and possibly split extensive methods into helper methods for clarity.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: .github/copilot-instructions.md
Category: Maintainability
Severity: Medium
Title: Lack of Version Control for Contribution Guidelines
Description: The contribution guidelines note that this file should be updated as the project evolves, but it doesn't specify a versioning or review process. Without proper versioning or control, there may be inconsistencies or outdated practices followed by contributors.
Recommendation: Implement a version control system (e.g., using Git tags or maintaining a CHANGELOG) to track changes in contribution guidelines and ensure contributors work with the most up-to-date practices.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: docs/httpclient-il-plan.md
Category: Maintainability
Severity: Medium
Title: High-level Approach Lacks Clear Prioritization
Description: The plan mentions multiple actionable steps but does not indicate any prioritization or timeline for when these steps will be addressed. This could lead to confusion among team members about which tasks to focus on first.
Recommendation: Add a section that prioritizes the tasks in the high-level approach. Consider including estimated completion times or a workflow diagram to visualize the plan better.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: src/Core/DefaultState/DefaultStateEvaluator.cs
Category: Performance
Severity: Medium
Title: Potential Memory Leak due to ConcurrentDictionary
Description: The Cache is declared as a ConcurrentDictionary, but not managed properly. If types are frequently checked and cache entries are continuously added without a plan for expiration, it could lead to a memory leak.
Recommendation: Implement a cache expiration policy or periodically clean the cache to remove entries that are no longer used. This can ensure that memory usage remains optimal.

[DenisZhukovski]

File: src/Constructors/DefaultStateConstructor.cs
Category: Performance
Severity: Medium
Title: Inefficient Constructor Call
Description: The Equals method is comparing the object equality using the _object field directly, which may lead to performance issues with large object graphs. Depending on how the object is implemented, this might lead to unnecessary performance penalties.
Recommendation: Consider overriding Equals with a more efficient implementation that minimizes deep equality checks or utilizes a cached hash value rather than comparing whole object graphs.

[sonarqubecloud]

Quality Gate failed

Failed conditions
70.2% Coverage on New Code (required ≥ 80%)

See analysis details on SonarQube Cloud