Transcoding MP4 to MP4 not possible - destroyed structure

[fzold]

Tested with v8.08 - 09. The encoding is flawless, but in the end you get a non-playable MP4. However, the encoding from MP4 to MKV is fine.
This from NVEncC v8.09:

And if you go back to v.7.82:

The result is ok.

But I have identified another issue. In both versions - old and new - no psnr or vmaf is possible if you read from mp4. No error, but the status line is not being output.

[rigaya]

Would you please let me know exactly what option have you used for this encoding and the information of the input file, as I generally have no problem in H.264 mp4 to mp4 encode when using 8.08 - 8.09?

Also, does this also happen in HEVC or AV1 encoding?

[fzold]

First my script:

ECHO Changing Power Plan to avoid sleep/hibernate (Höchstleistung).
powercfg -s SCHEME_MIN

ECHO Encoding started %date% %time%
SETLOCAL EnableDelayedExpansion

  NVEncC64.exe --log-level info --thread-priority belownormal ^
  --avhw -i "Wendland.S01E03.StillerundderroteFaden1.mp4" ^
  -c h264 --profile high -u p6 --qvbr 25 ^
  --gop-len 50 --bframes 3 --lookahead 20 ^
  --max-bitrate 8000 --avsync cfr ^
  --chapter chapters.txt --key-on-chapter ^
  --colorprim bt709 --colormatrix bt709 --transfer bt709 ^
  --video-metadata title="NVEncC cq 25" ^
  --audio-copy 1 ^
  --metadata date=2023 --metadata season_number=01 --metadata episode_sort=03 --metadata artist="Ulrich Noethen" ^
  --metadata title="Wendland - S01E03 Stiller und der rote Faden" ^
  -o "xWendland.S01E03.StillerundderroteFaden.mp4"

ECHO.
ECHO Encoding finished %date% %time%

ECHO Restoring normal Power Plan.
powercfg -s SCHEME_BALANCED

PAUSE
EXIT /B

Will test a little more.

[fzold]

Got it.
The source audio was EAC3 2.0.
The line --audio-copy 1 for this track is the culprit. If I use external audio:
--audio-source audio.ec3:copy
it works in v8.09.
So I tested AC3 too - same behavior.

Results for h264:
AC3 and EAC3 tracks cannot be copied from MP4 to MP4.
AAC audio tracks are working.

In MP4 the audio standard is AAC, but AC3, EAC3 is allowed. Nowadays WEB sources use that for multi-channel and Dolby Atmos.

[fzold]

My player is mpv on Win11 Pro.