Skip to content

Cryptic error when using comma-separated declaration syntax in SharedDefinitions #76

@rbohrer

Description

@rbohrer

See attached MWE. When I use comma-separated syntax to declare multiple uninterpreted symbols in a single declaration in the SharedDefinitions section, I get the following error message, which was less clear than expected. This only occurred with the SharedDefinitions section. The other sections worked fine.

I know there's a special step in KeYmaera X that takes the shared definitions and turns them into regular definitions that get duplicated across each theorem. If I had to guess, maybe something goes wrong at that step. But I have not checked at all, it's merely a guess.

Got: parser error message:

At line -1:-1: Even though archive parses, extracted problem does not parse (try reformatting): SharedDefinitions Real x, , y. End. Theorem "ReproduceCrypticErrorForCommaSeparatedConstantDeclarations" Problem. (x()+y())^2 >= 0 End. End.

Expected: Either the syntax is supported or the error message is more specific (e.g. points to the comma and says it's invalid syntax)

MWE:
CommaSeparatedSharedDefinitionsCrypticError.kyx.txt

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions